Vocabulary dictionary

Kanji dictionary

Grammar dictionary

Sentence lookup

test
 

Forums - Should +verb

Top > 日本語を勉強しましょう / Let's study Japanese! > Anything About Japanese



avatar
Venia9
Level: 13

Should + verb in Japanese is :

~なければならない / ~なきゃならない

And for me(a bit lazy😅) the best one is: ~なきゃ

So.. would it look soo rude using ~なきゃ... and is there a better way for (should )???

0
3 days ago
avatar
むじな
Level: 635

Like in any language, you adjust your level of laziness in speaking depending on the social situation and how formal it is. The more shortened, the less formal. Of course, deciding "this feels easiest for now, so I'll just always use this" works when you're just starting out and it's all a bit overwhelming, particularly when the people you're talking to know you're still learning.

Also, give べきだ/べきではない a look. It's actually closer to the English "should", while なければならない is more of a "must/have to".

2
2 days ago
avatar
Venia9
Level: 13

むじな (1231, 8:15)

Like in any language, you adjust your level of laziness in speaking depending on the social situation and how formal it is. The more shortened, the less formal. Of course, deciding "this feels easiest for now, so I'll just always use this" works when you're just starting out and it's all a bit overwhelming, particularly when the people you're talking to know you're still learning.

Also, give べきだ/べきではない a look. It's actually closer to the English "should", while なければならない is more of a "must/have to".


In fact, my problem is the pronunciation of the word .. ~なければならない... My tongue will get twisted before I say it correctly🥲

Anyway.. I'll use べきだ in this case.... easy... and not a tongue-twister

ありがとう👍️

0
2 days ago
avatar
むじな
Level: 635

Do note that they mean slightly different things, though.

1
2 days ago
avatar
Venia9
Level: 13

むじな (1231, 11:43)

Do note that they mean slightly different things, though.

Is it like.. one is stronger then the other??

Like べきだ :should

~なければならない: must

???


0
2 days ago
avatar
むじな
Level: 635

Venia9 (1231, 13:55)

むじな (1231, 11:43)

Do note that they mean slightly different things, though.

Is it like.. one is stronger then the other??

Like べきだ :should

~なければならない: must

???


The simple answer would be yes, you're right. But there's a lot of nuance involved depending on the context. You could say (I'm no expert, mind you, so I may be wrong) that:

べき refers to the right thing to do to obtain or attain something (demonstrably or morally right): ともっとすべきもんだよ。

- while なきゃ is something you simply have to do (often as a result of outside circumstances, not necessarily your own choice or judgment) or else there will be unwanted consequences. It's a little like the difference between "must" and "have to" in English.


But, again, I may be wrong about the finer nuances. In real life, "term A = term B" rarely works anyway.

2
2 days ago
avatar
Venia9
Level: 13

むじな (1231, 13:30)

Venia9 (1231, 13:55)

むじな (1231, 11:43)

Do note that they mean slightly different things, though.

Is it like.. one is stronger then the other??

Like べきだ :should

~なければならない: must

???

The simple answer would be yes, you're right. But there's a lot of nuance involved depending on the context. You could say (I'm no expert, mind you, so I may be wrong) that:

べき refers to the right thing to do to obtain or attain something (demonstrably or morally right): ともっとすべきもんだよ。

- while なきゃ is something you simply have to do (often as a result of outside circumstances, not necessarily your own choice or judgment) or else there will be unwanted consequences. It's a little like the difference between "must" and "have to" in English.


But, again, I may be wrong about the finer nuances. In real life, "term A = term B" rarely works anyway.

These are important informations to note..

ありがとうございました

0
1 day ago
Getting the posts




Top > 日本語を勉強しましょう / Let's study Japanese! > Anything About Japanese


Loading the list
Lv.

Sorry, there was an error on renshuu! If it's OK, please describe what you were doing. This will help us fix the issue.

Characters to show:





Use your mouse or finger to write characters in the box.
■ Katakana ■ Hiragana